What does “That is a very strong historical point” mean?
strong does not mean:
“This is definitely true because it sounds convincing.”
It means:
The claim has substantial evidentiary or scholarly support and is particularly useful for the argument you are constructing.
For example:
“Formerly enslaved people remained economically disadvantaged because they lacked access to land.”
That is stronger than merely saying:
“Former slaves were probably poor.”
Why?
Because the first claim can be supported by historical evidence concerning:
land ownership,
labor arrangements,
tenancy,
sharecropping,
credit,
economic dependence.
Comments
Post a Comment