“Institutional or disciplinary gatekeeping”

This means that the filtering happens through either:

Institutional mechanisms

Such as:

  • funding committees;
  • hiring committees;
  • journals;
  • universities;
  • promotion systems.

or:

Disciplinary mechanisms

Such as:

  • methodological norms;
  • accepted standards of evidence;
  • dominant theoretical frameworks;
  • professional expectations.

For example:

A paper is rejected because reviewers say its methodology violates accepted historical standards.

That is potentially disciplinary gatekeeping.

If:

a university refuses to fund the project,

that is more clearly institutional gatekeeping.

They can overlap.

Comments