“Operation of the scholarly system”

This means:

how the scholarly system actually functions in practice.

For example, you might discover:

Scholars from prestigious universities receive substantially more citations even when publication volume and field are similar.

That raises a question:

Why?

Perhaps prestige affects:

  • visibility;
  • networking;
  • conference invitations;
  • editorial attention;
  • collaboration;
  • students' awareness;
  • citation behavior.

You are no longer merely describing:

“Professor X has many citations.”

You are investigating:

What mechanisms cause some scholarly work to become more visible and influential than other comparable work?

That is what I mean by studying the operation of the scholarly system.

Comments