“Evidence about how the scholarly system operates” rather than one scholar's citation count Consider two different studies. Study 1: One scholar You discover: Professor X has 20,000 citations. That tells you something about Professor X's scholarly visibility . But it doesn't tell you why. Perhaps: Professor X produced excellent research; Professor X works in a very large field; the scholar has been publishing for 40 years; the work is highly influential; the work is fashionable; the scholar belongs to a prestigious institution. Study 2: Systematic pattern Now imagine you study 500 historians and discover: Historians at elite institutions are cited substantially more often than similarly productive historians at less prestigious institutions, even after controlling for publication volume and field. That tells you something potentially important about the operation of the scholarly system . You can then ask: Does institutional prestige influe...
Posts
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
The West Bank barrier built by Israel and the historic Berlin Wall both involve major physical divisions, but they differ fundamentally in purpose and context. Israel started its barrier in 2002 to stop attacks, while East Germany built the Berlin Wall in 1961 to keep its own citizens from leaving. The international community views and responds to them in very different ways. Key Differences in Purpose and Location Berlin Wall: Built entirely inside sovereign East German territory to enclose a population and prevent emigration to the West. West Bank Barrier: Built across disputed territory and parts of the West Bank to manage security and stop infiltration from outside, though a large portion deviates from the Green Line onto Palestinian land. Similarities Severe Disruption: Both structures cut through existing urban areas, separated families, and blocked daily movement. Deep Symbolism: Both became globally recognized symbols of political division, ideological conflict, and restri...
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
The Israeli West Bank barrier is a 708-kilometer (440-mile) separation structure of fences, concrete walls, and trenches built by Israel. Termed a separation or apartheid wall, criticized for annexing land, separating families, and restricting Palestinian movement and access to work or agriculture. International Standing: The International Court of Justice issued an advisory opinion in 2004 deeming the portions built inside the occupied territory contrary to international law, a view supported by various United Nations resolutions
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
“The structure is related to the scholarly outcome.” structure means the relatively enduring institutional and social arrangements within which scholars operate. For example: universities; funding systems; journals; peer-review procedures; academic departments; professional associations; curricula; promotion systems; citation practices; research grants; government research priorities. What is “scholarly outcome”? An outcome is what eventually emerges from the scholarly process. Examples: which subjects receive extensive research; which interpretations become dominant; which scholars become prominent; which books are frequently cited; which topics enter university curricula; which arguments are accepted as legitimate; which interpretations receive repeated publication. So suppose you discover: Universities repeatedly fund research on Topic A but rarely fund Topic B. and: Journals consequently contain many studies of Topic A but very few of Topic B. Then you could investigate wheth...
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
“Records can be destroyed or never created.” But if absence is real, how do we prove it, and what would it prove? This requires an important distinction: A. Absence of evidence You search for evidence and do not find it. For example: “I searched the university archive and found no record that Professor X received funding.” That is an absence of evidence . But it does not necessarily establish: “Professor X never received funding.” Why? The record could have: been destroyed; never been created; been misclassified; been stored somewhere else; not been digitized. B. Evidence of absence This is stronger. You have evidence showing that something was absent . For example, suppose a university has an official funding database that: records every grant awarded ; has existed continuously from 2000–2020; has a documented procedure requiring every grant to be entered; has complete records for the relevant period; contains no grant for Professor X. N...
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
When the proposition can often be your own reasoned explanation, particularly when it is a straightforward consequence then you do not need to pretend that a historian said it if you are the one formulating it. The important thing is simply to signal the status correctly when it is not already established—for example: “This suggests that…” or “A plausible consequence was…” rather than presenting a disputed causal interpretation as an established historical fact
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
“War economy” A war economy is the economic system and production structure supporting military conflict. It includes: food production, weapons, clothing, transportation, construction, labor, taxation, supplies, logistics. For the Confederacy, enslaved labor was important to agricultural production, particularly cotton and food production, while enslaved people were also extensively used in military-support work. Therefore, disrupting the system of enslaved labor could affect the war economy , even if the Confederate government rejected the legal basis of emancipation.