Why is “false” stronger than “misleading”?
Consider:
“The Earth is round.”
False means:
The proposition itself does not correspond to reality.
Misleading is different.
A statement can be individually true but produce a false impression.
Example
Suppose I say:
“Professor X published 50 articles.”
That is true.
But suppose I deliberately omit:
45 of those articles were minor pieces and the professor's major research contribution was very limited.
My statement isn't necessarily false.
But if I present it to create the impression:
“Professor X is an exceptionally influential scholar,”
it could be misleading.
Comments
Post a Comment