The act of referring is as dubious as the reference itself By Dr sohail Ansari
“The unjust shall not have any
compassionate friend nor any intercessor who should be obeyed.” Qur'an, 40:18. “Learn to do
good; seek justice, correct oppression; bring justice to the
fatherless, and please the widow's cause,” (Isaiah 1:17).
(I LAUGH BUT BELATEDLY part 3)
Citation can never be for the
sake of it. “Citing” refers to
giving an example of some subject for substantiating oneself. Examples are given and books or sites are cited to
develop claims or to counter any reasoning.
A responder states: ‘problem is
that the left likes to scream all the time, and that’s what we end up hearing’
Left
misguides through screaming (that black
suffers otherwise reality is otherwise) is what a responder suggests,
therefore, to put us in the right
perspective a responder should have cited some conservative and right-wing
media, but he refers to https://thesaker.is/the-systemic-collapse-of-the-us-society-has-begun/
that claims to be the left wing media.
A very short book, “The Three
Languages of Politics” by Arnold Kling offers a way to see through our rhetorical blinders so that
we can incorporate new perspectives, and nuances. This book defines a left-leaning vs right-leaning media: The
basic idea is that one group (left one) tends to evaluate things on a scale of
oppressed vs oppressor, another group (right one) tends to evaluate things on a
scale of civilization vs barbarianism.
John Barnes writes:
‘The best way to tell the political bias of a web site, newspaper or any other
media is to observe who is demonized and who is praised. Progressive or
left-leaning web sites favor Democratic politicians (Hillary Clinton, Chuck
Schumer, etc.) and leftist academics such as Paul Krugman and Norm Chomsky. The
New York Times is the Left’s primus inter pares newspaper. Huffington Post is
probably the most popular leftist website, where you can pick up leftist
talking points as provided by Moveon.org,
which tends to originate many leftist ideas, which ‘fellow travelers’ then
parrot.’
One
is informed before he reads an article: The systemic collapse of the US society
‘that this article was written for the Unz Review. The Unz Review claims to be the alternative media that
offers a collection of interesting, important and controversial perspectives
largely excluded from the American mainstream media.
The book ‘Alternative Media’ by Atton
and Chris states: ‘Alternative media tend to be non-commercial projects
that advocate the interests of those excluded from the mainstream, for example,
the poor, political and ethnic minorities, labor groups, and LGBT identities.
There are two good academic studies : ‘Fissures in the mediascape : an international study of
citizens' media by Clemencia Rodriguez. And ‘Alternative
and Activist New Media’ by Leah A. Lievrouw.
Both
books agree that: ‘Alternative media
challenge the dominant beliefs and values of a culture and have been described
as "counter-hegemonic" by adherents of Antonio Gramsci's theory of cultural hegemony.
Antonio
Francesco Gramsci was an Italian Marxist philosopher and communist politician. Antonio Gramsci is famous for his theory
of cultural hegemony In Marxist philosophy, cultural
hegemony is the domination of a culturally
diverse society by the ruling class who manipulate the culture of that
society —
‘Alternative media thus have to be left media. The Unz Review claims to be the alternative media, but do
not seem to be living up to its claim because instead of being "counter-hegemonic" by disseminating
marginalized viewpoints, and advocating the interests of those excluded from
the mainstream, Unz Review through the article: ‘The systemic collapse of the US society’ rationalizes and
condones the violence against black and sanitizes the brutalities unleashed
against black by the white.
Comments
Post a Comment